In partnership with

Before a buyer calls a listing a bargain, check what went into the square footage. A finished lower level can change the comparison without changing the house.

Good morning, NREB readers.

As always, we’re here to keep real estate professionals informed while cutting out the fluff. Let’s get right into it.

A buyer sends you two listings and a conclusion: this one is a better deal because the price per square foot is lower.

It is an understandable shortcut. The number looks objective, and it gives buyers something concrete to compare when the photos, descriptions, and asking prices tell different stories.

But before discussing whether the cheaper-looking home is actually a bargain, there is a more basic question: Are those listings counting the same kind of space?

One house, two very different ratios

Consider a hypothetical home listed at $600,000. It has 2,400 square feet of finished space above ground and another 600 square feet in a finished lower level that is partly below ground.

Divide the price by all 3,000 finished square feet, and the result is $200 per square foot.

Divide it by the 2,400 above-grade square feet, and the result is $250 per square foot.

The house did not change. Neither did the asking price. The calculation changed because the area used in it changed.

That does not establish which figure belongs in a particular MLS field, and it does not establish the home’s value. It shows why two apparently comparable price-per-square-foot figures can be answering different questions.

If one listing includes finished lower-level space in the number you use and another reports it separately, the resulting comparison can make one home look cheaper before you have evaluated either property.

Become An AI Expert In Just 5 Minutes

If you’re a decision maker at your company, you need to be on the bleeding edge of, well, everything. But before you go signing up for seminars, conferences, lunch ‘n learns, and all that jazz, just know there’s a far better (and simpler) way: Subscribing to The Deep View.

This daily newsletter condenses everything you need to know about the latest and greatest AI developments into a 5-minute read. Squeeze it into your morning coffee break and before you know it, you’ll be an expert too.

Subscribe right here. It’s totally free, wildly informative, and trusted by 600,000+ readers at Google, Meta, Microsoft, and beyond.

Separately reported does not mean worthless

Fannie Mae’s appraisal guidance makes this distinction especially clear. It treats an entire level as below grade if any part of that level is below grade, regardless of the quality of the finishes or the size of its windows.

That includes a finished walkout level that feels very much like the rest of the house. It is reported separately from the above-grade area.

But Fannie Mae also explicitly recognizes that these rooms can add substantial value. Keeping space out of the above-grade total does not erase its contribution to the property.

This matters when a seller hears that an appraiser reported fewer above-grade square feet than the total they remember. Before anyone concludes that the appraiser missed a room, check where the area appears in the report.

These are appraisal reporting rules, not a universal instruction for filling out every MLS listing. Follow the definitions and requirements that apply in your market, and make the distinctions clear to clients.

Check the source before defending the number

The useful question is not simply, “How many square feet?” It is, “Where did this figure come from, and what does it include?”

For a property under discussion, establish three things:

  • The source: a measurement, tax record, floor plan, prior listing, or another source.

  • The categories: whether above-grade space, finished lower-level space, and other areas are identified separately.

  • The comparison: whether the properties you are comparing use consistent categories and are otherwise reasonably similar.

A discrepancy deserves an explanation. Sometimes the issue is a measurement. Sometimes it is which areas were combined. Copying a previous listing does not settle either question.

If the difference could affect a pricing or offer decision, resolve it early with the appropriate records and, where needed, qualified measurement help. A buyer should not have to discover after committing that the number driving their comparison meant something different from what they assumed.

The ratio still is not a price tag for every extra foot

Even with consistent measurements, price per square foot has limits.

The numerator is the price of the whole property, including its land, location, condition, layout, and other features. Dividing that price by the home’s area does not isolate what an additional square foot is worth.

In the example above, $250 per above-grade square foot does not mean the 600-square-foot lower level should automatically be valued at $150,000. Nor does it establish the appropriate adjustment for a larger comparable home.

Fannie Mae requires appraisal adjustments to reflect the market’s response to differences between properties, rather than an arbitrary per-foot rule.

Price per square foot can help organize a comparison. It becomes more useful once you know the measurements are consistent and the homes are genuinely comparable.

When a client brings you the number, start with the space behind it. That is how a quick calculation becomes a better-informed conversation.

Sources

When your next client asks, have more to work with.

NREB Premium takes one real estate problem further every Saturday, with deeper analysis and practical tools such as worked numbers, client-ready scripts, and negotiation guidance.

Join today for the complete Premium archive, plus a new briefing delivered to your inbox each week.

$9.99/month or $99.99/year.

Keep Reading