Good evening, NREB readers!
The buyer sounds like someone you'd be happy to work with.
They're preapproved. They've found a house they want to see. They say they're ready to make an offer if the property looks right.
Then comes the complication.
“We were working with another agent, but they're impossible to get ahold of. We're done with them. Can you show us the house tonight?”
The easy answer is yes. The cautious answer is to call your broker.
But neither is quite enough.
If the buyer signed an exclusive representation agreement, their frustration does not necessarily terminate it. If they signed a nonexclusive or property-specific agreement, the situation could be much more straightforward. And if they have already been released, that still might not answer whether the former brokerage has a compensation claim involving this particular property.
The opportunity isn't necessarily off-limits. But permission to talk with the buyer, show the property, represent them, and receive compensation can be four different questions.
Knowing which question you're answering is what keeps a promising new relationship from becoming a problem.

Why “we fired our agent” isn't the answer
Written buyer agreements have become routine since the National Association of REALTORS®' August 2024 MLS practice changes. Under the applicable policy, an MLS participant working with a buyer must have a written agreement before touring a home, including a live virtual tour.
But the agreement doesn't have to be exclusive, cover an entire market, or last several months.
NAR's Written Buyer Agreements 101 explains that permissible arrangements can differ in duration, property coverage, services, and representation type, subject to state law.
That creates some important distinctions.
Consider three hypothetical buyers:
Buyer A signed a nonexclusive agreement covering one condominium. They now want to tour a different property.
Buyer B signed a 60-day exclusive agreement covering residential purchases in the area. Their agent stopped returning their calls, but the agreement hasn't expired.
Buyer C received a written release from their prior brokerage. However, the new property was previously shown by that brokerage, and the original agreement contains a post-termination compensation provision.
All three might sincerely believe they are free to switch agents.
Their documents may tell three very different stories.
What NAR's ethics rules actually permit
Article 16 of NAR's 2026 Code of Ethics requires REALTORS® to respect existing exclusive representation relationships.
But the rules are more nuanced than a blanket prohibition on talking to another agent's client.
Standard of Practice 16-6 permits certain discussions about a future exclusive relationship when the client of another REALTOR® contacts you independently, without your having directly or indirectly initiated those discussions.
Standard of Practice 16-9 requires reasonable efforts to determine whether a prospective client is already subject to a current, valid exclusive agreement before entering into representation.
And Standard of Practice 16-13 requires asking about exclusive representation before providing substantive services. It recognizes exceptions involving the existing representative's consent or the prospect's direction.
That last exception matters. Being approached by a represented buyer does not automatically prohibit every service or conversation.
But it also doesn't erase the buyer's underlying contract, override state law, or eliminate the separate MLS written-agreement requirement when applicable.
A real NAR ethics case illustrates the danger of skipping the inquiry.
In Case #16-22, an agent met a buyer at an open house. The buyer acknowledged working with another agent. The first agent offered a showing of another property and eventually wrote an offer.
The buyer's existing representative filed an ethics complaint.
The hearing panel found an Article 16 violation because the agent had not made reasonable efforts to determine whether the buyer's existing relationship was exclusive.
The lesson isn't that an agent must reject every buyer who has worked with someone else.
It's that a buyer's willingness to proceed is not the same thing as establishing which obligations still exist.
The decision you have to make before the showing
When the buyer wants to tour in two hours, you have a limited window to establish the facts without making them feel interrogated or abandoned.
You need to know whether the prior agreement covers the property and services involved, whether a new agreement can properly be established, and whether compensation obligations could survive even after representation ends.
And you need language that protects the buyer's interests without making the new relationship sound like a legal obstacle course.
Here's the practical question: What do you say right now, and what changes depending on the paperwork the buyer sends you?
The complete briefing walks through three realistic buyer-transfer cases with different outcomes, the exact first-call response, the contract provisions most likely to change the decision, and a reusable Buyer Transfer Check for your next incoming prospect.
The goal isn't to avoid every buyer who has another agent. It's to recognize when you can proceed, when you need a documented clarification, and when a seemingly straightforward showing could create a much bigger problem.
NREB Premium members receive the complete decision guide, scripts, and the full archive of previous professional briefings.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Already a member? Sign in to NREB.news |
